Tag Archives: organic

Mrs. Smith’s 3rd grade class designs Facebook’s Video algorithm, or so it seems

It is no secret that Facebook is competing with other social apps in a determined effort to be all things to everyone and the last app standing. A short time back they took on YouTube in an attempt for most video views. To accomplish this they rewarded Fans who uploaded video directly rather than using a YouTube link with better looks, autoplay, metrics and, most importantly, increased Views and Reach. If you upload a video directly to Facebook you get an algorithm bonus and Facebook pushes you higher and wider so more people will see your post. This was like magic to many small businesses that saw the views on their posts 10’s, 100’s and even 1000’s times higher than ever before.

This client had a modest 2,000 Fans on their page. These results are Organic

facebook organic video results

Facebook video statistics for Organic video results

This all seems like an incredible gift, and it is, but there are complications created by Facebook that are outside the control of Page Owners. First it is about reasonable expectation setting. Videos receiving many times their normal expected Reach and Engagement can put a shop owner’s head in the clouds. And all too quickly the realization that this was an anomaly not likely repeated can be a real let down. But lack of control is probably the most disconcerting. The two charts below paint a queer picture of how Facebook chose to twist this client’s marketing efforts.

Facebook Demographic of Fans on page and those reached by video post

Facebook Demographic of Fans on page and those reached by video post

The chart on the left shows the Fans of the Page. The breakdown is as the client requested with a greater focus on U.S. and a smaller number for their Hong Kong headquarters. Additionally, India is a focus for select inventory. The demographic targeting is accurate. However, the Fans Reached in the month of the “great” video shows a markedly different Reach with Malaysia, a non-target country, receiving 50% of all views. Small businesses benefit from precise marketing to make sure money and effort is not wasted. So it is curious why Facebook’s video algorithm decided that a country excluded from the client’s target market now be included? As this action was created from the Facebook algorithm there was no way for the Page owner to influence, redirect or even object.

As we see Facebook and other social sites try and increase Engagement rates to demonstrate relevance we will likely continue to see marketing actions that are outside the Page owner’s control or wishes. Taking this to a logical conclusion of how does Facebook make money off of this I can only conclude that as Facebook takes more control away from non-sponsored ads they will be encouraging Facebook page owners to regain control through paid targeted promotions. And of course there is social media optimization which continues to be a powerful marketing tool.

Much success,

Doug

http://www.PRDA.Asia

PRDA Asia

http://www.PRDA.Asia is a leading social media management agency

Incubator 2.0: Social Cooperation for SME and Start up Marketing

A new way of doing business is here. Most don’t even recognise it yet, but they take part in it daily. It is collaborative or cooperative marketing. Whereas there is still flexibility in the definition, it is based on the  simple common sense ideas as strength in numbers and the sum of the parts are greater than the whole. But it is also based in sound results data which makes it undeniable.cooperate definition

Jeremiah Owyang (@JOwyang) has recently released some powerful financial data on the “collaborative” economy reaching back to 2002.  His definition is about technology that allows for efficient sharing of services such as UBER and AirBNB. This definition has popularity as it is the basis for most current start up models.

Small Business Saturday takes social cooperation to the streets. Started by American Express to coordinate marketing efforts of SME’s to promote sales for the Saturday following Thanksgiving in the U.S., it has proven hugely successful. As reported in an article by CNN in 2012 SME’s reported that Black Friday and Cyber Monday had little effect on their sales, but the coordinated marketing effort for Small Business Saturday delivered US$5.5 billion in sales for the day. Note Black Friday, which favours large retail outlets, saw only US$1 billion in sales in 2012.

Ashton Kutcher (@aplusk) is developing the extended incubator. Having seen the success of other incubators such as Y-Combinator has envisioned extending beyond development to product launch. In the incubator model, resources and knowledge are brought together to provide a heightened environment for success. However, there does not exist an “incubator” for after the product is developed. How do you go from not known to a necessity?

In these three examples I touched on three key points of Incubator 2.0 or as I like to call it the Social Media Cooperative. And the there is the fourth which differentiates  from the common aggregator model which collects and lists businesses under a single brand (e.g. Uber, Expedia, Yelp). The key points are:

  • Having a platform and interface that allows SME’s to join, contribute and participate
  • SME’s power the world, they generate more revenue and employ more people than the multinationals could even dream about. SME’s ROCK!
  • There needs to be an effective model where SME”s can tap into an existing collective of resources and knowledge
  • Rather than aggregate the model needs to propagate

Unlocking the secrets of social media:

Fundamental to all social media and including search is Like, Comment and Share. The more you do, the better the results. This model suggests that instead of creating an app that aggregates businesses such as Groupon mobile app which may have 100,000 businesses represented, we advocate establishing digital footprints for each brand. This would mean 100,000 Facebook pages, Twitter accounts, Instagram streams, Blogs etc. and the good search that results from this optimised content. But more importantly you have 100,000 healthy communities built of Fans/ customers that have joined these brands because they chose to. Consider this, which do you think is more valuable to a business for ROI?

  • Having 10,000 Fans on your page that chose to be there and are actively engaged
  • Paying Facebook to push your ad to 10,000 random people

Next Step:

Now that we have these 100,000 businesses how do we get it to work? Technology and expertise play a large role. Social media is all about understanding algorithms and online consumer behaviour. By leveraging knowledge of these along with a proven process and a technology backend driven by a crowdsourcing model, science becomes magic. By effectively posting on these 100,000 businesses profiles using optimised content and then systematically cross promoting through Share, Like and Comment we have proven to increase Organic reach by 20 times! And in addition to an increase in organic reach, each brand that cross promotes using Likes, Comments and Shares gets exposed to a new and wider range of Fans/ customers. This works the same way as when we share a post from a friend and in doing so all our friends get to see this post and they also get to see who it originally came from.

Cooperation:

This can only work with cooperation. SME’s must recognise the value in sharing promotion. What we have found odd is that a brand will not hesitate having their advertisement on the same website, newspaper page or bus stop as other businesses, but they hesitate when asked to cross promote. This is where successful activities like Small Business Saturday are proving that by sharing and cooperating a business does not jeopardise their brand and market share, but in fact, increases it.

Better understanding:

The technology and process is too detailed to go into here. PRDA has been proving this concept for 6 years and it has remained successful despite changes to algorithms or popular apps. Fundamentals change more slowly and the concept of cooperation being good for outcome likely to not change anytime soon.

Immediate benefits:

  • Access to a large pool of engaged Fans/ customers through shared communities
  • Highly effective organic results and search through optimised content
  • Efficiency of process, technology and scale:
    • Reduced cost
    • Increased performance
    • Reduced risk
    • Increased services
  • Big Data

 

Much success,

Doug

PRDA Asia

http://www.PRDA.Asia is a leading social media management agency

Facebook why don’t you like Mom’s and Chinese Language?

Dear Facebook,

Facebook advertising seems to unfairly target Chinese language and Mothers to be for rejections. My agency PRDA Asia uses  the Facebook advert platform for our clients and have about 200 adverts running at any time. The rejection rate is low at about 4 per week so that is good. What is odd is that they seem to fall clearly into 2 categories:

  • Chinese language rejected for profanity
  • Anything to do with pregnant women

Chinese language profane? Mark’s profile on Facebook states he knows Mandarin and his wife, Priscilla Chan speaks Cantonese and whereas I don’t think they personally review every Chinese language ad, it seems that there should be some basic understanding. Chinese language adverts routinely get rejected for being “vulgar” or “threatening” which is silly as even the embarrassingly bad Google translate shows they are not.  I am thinking Facebook may not be happy with China?

FB Chinese ad rejected

The embarrassingly bad Google translation may be unintelligible but it is not profane.

“Maybe you have seen it and not know canal system baa # fruit, drainage structures similar shape with cherry tomatoes. Canal baa? Actually canal called Physalis, Zhong many benefits of rack!”

Pregnant women get no break with Facebook. If you have a baby bump get used to a difficult time on Facebook ad platform. Pregnant women are different than non-pregnant women and Facebook seems to have a problem with “different”.  The rejection below is absurd. If Demi Moore can pose nude while pregnant well then what do you have to say Facebook?

Facebook dislikes mothers

Or this one which is even more curious. Eating well while pregnant suggests achieving and ideal body shape? Hummmm, isn’t that the point and doesn’t biology have a little bit to do with the bump?

Facebook adverts dislike pregnant women

At PRDA  we use adverts sparingly as we are very good at organic results and believe that paid creates an unsustainable and artificial community where ROI and Fan satisfaction becomes difficult to interpret. However, it does have its use. That is why I find it alarming that we consistently run into problems with 2 categories of Adverts. Those in Chinese and those directed at Mothers to be. We will continue to promote our clients in an honest and engaging way to ensure that true Fans receive the information they need and feel good about sharing with their friends. Let’s hope that Facebook catches up to this concept soon.

Much success,

Doug

PRDA Asia

http://www.PRDA.Asia is a leading social media management agency